Insights

Appointment setting for IT consultancies: what to ask first

5 minute read

The first questions an IT consultancy should ask about appointment setting are about itself, not the provider. Decide who will take the meetings, which problems you want to be called about and what a worthwhile meeting looks like, then ask every provider the same three questions.

Most firms do this the other way round. They take a call from a provider, hear a pitch about volume and only later work out that their partners cannot hold the meetings, or do not want them. By then the market has heard from them in the wrong way.

This piece is about getting the order right. It is shorter than a full buyer’s guide on purpose. If you answer these eight questions before your first provider call, the rest of the choice gets much easier.

Part one: five questions for your own firm

1. Who will take the meetings?

Name them. In a consultancy the people buyers want to meet are your partners and senior consultants. They are also the people billing the most hours.

Write down who will attend first meetings, who will lead the follow-up and who can step in when a partner is on a client site. If the answer is “whoever is free”, the meetings will be lost to delivery within a month.

2. How many meetings can you actually hold?

Work this out from hours, not from a target. If three partners can each give two hours a week to new conversations, that is your ceiling, including preparation and follow-up.

It is usually fewer than firms expect. That is fine. A consultancy does not need many meetings. It needs the right ones. Any outside team should agree the pace with you before the first call and adjust it as diaries fill.

3. Which problems do you want to be called about?

A buyer will not take a meeting about your capabilities. They will take one about a problem they already have.

So list the problems you solve best, in the words a buyer would use. A migration that is running late. A contract with a supplier that ends next year. A board asking questions about security that nobody can answer. These become the reasons to call.

If you cannot list them, no caller can either.

4. Which accounts are off-limits?

Every consultancy has clients it already serves, opportunities in progress and relationships a partner has spent years building. None of them should receive a cold call.

Build the exclusion list now. Include current clients, live bids and anyone a partner knows personally. A good provider will ask for it on day one and never call those accounts.

5. What does a worthwhile meeting look like?

Agree this with your partners before you agree it with anyone else.

A useful starting point is priority, timeline and challenge with the right person at the right company. The buyer has a real priority. There is a date they are working to. There is a problem they cannot solve alone. And the person in the meeting owns the outcome and the budget.

Then add the partner test. After the first thirty meetings, how many would your partners say were worth the hours? Decide now what answer would make you carry on.

Part two: three questions for every provider

With those answers written down, the first provider conversation changes. You are no longer listening to a pitch. You are checking a fit.

Start with three questions. Ask them in this order, because each one rules providers out faster than the next.

1. What do you count as a result?

This is the question that separates the providers worth a second call.

If a booked slot counts, you will be sent booked slots. Some will not happen. Some will be with the wrong person. Your partners will notice before your reports do.

Look for a provider that counts a meeting only when it is held and qualified. Ours is held, then qualified on priority, timeline and challenge with the right person at the right company. No-shows and cancellations do not count. Ask to see the definition in writing and check it matches the one you wrote in part one.

2. Who will make the calls?

A consultancy sells judgement. The first voice a CIO hears from your firm should sound like it has some.

Ask how senior the caller is, what they have sold before and whether they are dedicated to your campaign. Ask to meet them. Ask to hear recent calls to buyers at the level you sell to. Ask what happens when they are on holiday or leave. Our campaigns have a named backup rep from day one, who knows the market before they are needed.

3. What happens before the first dial?

A provider that starts calling in the first week has not learned your firm.

Listen for workshops with your partners on your ideal clients and your proposition, research on your target accounts and call materials you approve. We spend two weeks on this before anyone calls. Ask how compliance is handled too. The ICO says live marketing calls must not go to TPS or CTPS numbers without consent, so every number should be screened first.

What to do with the answers

If a provider passes all three, go deeper. Hear more calls. Ask what you will see while the campaign runs. Ask what they record when a buyer is not ready yet, because most of the senior buyers a consultancy wants are not ready this quarter. Ask who owns that information when the contract ends.

If a provider fails the first question, you can stop there. Nothing else they offer will fix a loose definition of a meeting.

How this fits with a full buyer’s guide

We have written a longer guide that follows one partner through a whole year of choosing and running an outside programme. This piece comes before it. It is the half hour of work inside your own firm that makes the provider conversations short and honest.

Do that half hour first. Then bring a partner to the provider calls. They will be the person sitting in the meetings.

Read How we work to see how we answer the three provider questions.

Questions

What should an IT consultancy decide before talking to a provider?

Who will take the meetings, how many they can hold, which problems you want to be called about, which accounts are off-limits and what a worthwhile meeting looks like to a partner.

What is the first question to ask a provider?

Ask what they count as a result. If a booked slot counts, you will get booked slots. A meeting should count only when it is held and qualified with the right person.

How many meetings can a consultancy absorb?

Fewer than most firms think. Work it out from partner hours, not from a target. A provider should agree the pace with you before calling starts and adjust it as diaries fill.

Sources