Choose the agency whose reps you would be happy to put in front of your best account. Everything else on the shortlist matters less than who picks up the phone, how they are prepared and what the agency counts as a result.
Enterprise software is a hard place to outsource badly. Your buyers are senior. Your accounts are finite. A poor call does not just waste a dial. It burns a name you may need next year.
Buyers are also quick to judge. Gartner found that 61% of B2B buyers prefer a rep-free buying experience. An agency that sprays your name across a market can do lasting harm.
Hiring your own team has its own problems, including short tenure and slow ramp. That is why outsourcing is worth a look. It is not proof that any given agency is better.
Use the lists below as a working checklist. Tick an item only when you have heard the answer from the agency or seen it in writing. We are one of the firms you could choose, so the types of agency are described as fairly as we can at the end.
The reps
Senior buyers can tell within seconds whether the caller understands their world. So start with the people.
- Ask how much sales experience the reps have and what they have sold before.
- Ask where they sit.
- Meet the actual rep. You would not hire an account executive without an interview and this person will speak to more of your market than almost anyone in your business.
- Hear three recent calls to people at the level you sell to.
Dedication
Shared reps are cheaper. They also learn your market more slowly.
- Find out whether your rep works only on your campaign or shares the week with five other clients.
- Get the number of other clients that rep works on at the same time.
- Ask what happens if your rep leaves or goes on holiday.
Preparation
Enterprise buying is not a single conversation, so the first call has one job. It has to find the person who owns the problem and earn a real conversation. That takes preparation.
- Ask what happens before the first dial.
- Listen for account lists, buyer research and practice calls on your proposition.
- Treat a kick-off call and a script as a warning, because it will show on the phone.
- Ask what they learned on their last campaign in your sector that changed how they ran it.
Channels
Most agencies now describe themselves as multi-channel. A firm that books mainly from email is a different purchase from a firm that books mainly from the phone.
- Ask what share of meetings came from each channel on comparable campaigns.
- Decide which of those you want to buy before you compare prices.
The definition of a result
This is where most disappointment starts. Our own standard is priority, timeline and challenge with the right person at the right company. You may set yours differently, as long as it is written down.
- Get the definition of a qualified meeting in writing.
- Check whether the buyer must have a project, a problem or a timeline.
- Check whether a no-show counts.
- Check whether the meeting has to be held before you pay for it or count it.
- Ask what you will receive with each meeting.
Compliance
Your name is on those calls. The ICO is clear that live marketing calls must not go to numbers on the TPS or CTPS unless the subscriber has agreed.
- Ask how numbers are screened.
- Ask how objections are recorded.
Data and candour
When the contract ends, you should keep what was learned about your accounts. You should also expect to hear bad news early.
- Ask who owns the data and call intelligence if you stop working together.
- Ask what they will tell you in month two if the numbers are poor.
Reasons to walk away
Tick any of these and take that firm off your list.
- A guarantee of a fixed number of meetings before anyone has looked at your market. Nobody knows that number yet.
- A headline meeting count with no definition behind it. A booked meeting that never happens has cost your team time and told you nothing.
- No chance to meet the rep before you sign.
- Vague answers on who owns the data.
The types of agency to compare
These take different approaches, so compare them on what you actually need.
- A software specialist with global language coverage. This is worth a look if you need many languages and regions from one supplier.
- A broad managed programme for complex sales cycles, which can include white-labelled teams and native-language SDRs. This is worth a look if you also want lead conversion and account-based work.
- A managed multi-channel prospecting service, with replies and calls passed straight to your team. This suits firms that want outreach handled for them and their own team to take conversations forward.
- A phone-led senior team. This is Outbound Partners. We run phone-led outbound to senior buyers at IT services, consulting and enterprise software firms. Each client gets a dedicated senior UK rep and a named backup. We suit firms selling high-value deals to a defined list of accounts. We are not the cheapest route to volume and we will say so if volume is what you need.
Making the decision
A fair comparison beats a persuasive pitch, so run the same steps for every firm.
- Shortlist two or three firms.
- Hear real calls from each.
- Meet the actual rep.
- Read the meeting definition.
- Run the numbers against your own team using the same assumptions.
Read How we work to see how we answer every question on this list.