Insights

Why only one in five of your market will ever pick up

5 minute read

Only about one in five of your market will ever pick up because answering a cold call is a habit that some people have and most do not. More dials rarely change that, so the useful question is how quickly you can find the one in five.

That figure comes from our own call history and is published in PriorityDial’s methodology. Across our campaigns, roughly one in five contacts has ever answered a cold call, however many times they were dialled. The remaining four in five do not answer at any attempt.

What the figure means and what it does not

It does not say that one in five will buy. It does not say that one in five calls connect. It says that across a whole list, only about a fifth of the people have the behaviour of ever answering at all.

Nor does it say the other four are bad prospects. Many of them own budgets and run the very programmes you care about. They simply do not take calls from numbers they do not know. They may have an assistant who screens. They may keep their phone on silent. They may have decided years ago that unknown numbers go to voicemail.

The split also differs by market. Local habits and list quality both play a part. That is why we measure behaviour separately for each region.

Why more dials do not fix it

The natural response to a low answer rate is to dial more. It feels productive and it is easy to measure.

Look at what our own history shows. A number that has never answered is less likely to answer with every further attempt. Each further dial buys less than the last.

Meanwhile, the people who have answered before keep answering. Numbers that have picked up recently answer again far more often than fresh numbers do. So answering is closer to a trait than an accident.

There is a cost to the extra dials as well. If most of them go to people who will never pick up, the rep’s day is mainly voicemail. That is how a team talks itself out of using the phone.

The maths of a list

Take a list of a thousand contacts and ignore everything except the one in five.

About two hundred people on that list are reachable by phone. Your real target is a conversation with those two hundred. The other eight hundred are real people too, but they are not phone prospects for now.

Dial the list in order and those two hundred are scattered at random. You will spend most of the week getting to them. Dial them first and you spend the same effort on far fewer numbers.

This is why we are careful about the promise. Better ordering will not produce more conversations from the same list in the long run. The people who never answer still never answer. It gets you the same conversations from far fewer dials, so reps can spend the saved hours on more accounts.

How to find your one in five

Use your own history. You probably already know more than you think. Every connected call in your CRM tells you about a number that answers. Most teams never sort by it. Recent answers matter most. Our data shows the effect holds for about 150 days and fades by about 180.

Check the number types. Mobiles and direct lines behave differently from switchboards. A switchboard is not a contact. Sort them out early.

Verify before you dial. A live check on each number separates working lines from dead ones and finds who picks up. In the UK, screen against the TPS and CTPS first and cap the number of checks. Our own product, PriorityDial, does this, but you can start with your own history for free.

Time your calls. The people who do answer tend to answer at predictable times, which differ by role and region. Measure this on your own campaigns, because general advice on the best time to call rarely holds across markets.

Accept when to stop. Set a limit for attempts on a number that has never answered and then move on. Keep a record of what you tried, so that nobody starts the same sequence again next quarter.

What to do about the other four in five

Do not write them off. Change the route.

Some will reply to a short, relevant email. Volume does not fix this channel either, because buyers avoid suppliers who send irrelevant outreach.

Some can be reached through a colleague. The person who does pick up in the same team can often tell you who owns the problem and when to approach them. A referral from inside the account is one of the best first lines you can have.

Some will come through events, peers or the people who advise them. Those routes take longer. They are the job of your wider marketing and partner teams.

What this means for your targets

If you set activity targets without this number, you will reward the wrong behaviour. A team measured on dials will keep calling people who do not answer because it hits the target.

Measure conversations instead. Then measure how many dials it took to get each one. Your own trend matters more than any benchmark. If dials per conversation are falling, your list order is getting better.

See how we plan around the four in five in How we work.

Questions

What share of contacts will ever answer a cold call?

Across our campaigns, roughly one in five contacts has ever answered a cold call, however many times they were dialled. The other four in five do not answer at any attempt.

Will more dials reach the other four in five?

Rarely. Each extra attempt on a number that has never answered is less likely to work than the last. Further dials are better spent on new contacts or on people who have answered before.

Does one in five mean most of the market cannot be reached?

It means most of the market cannot be reached by cold call. Those buyers may still respond to email, referrals, events or a colleague who does pick up, so plan other routes for them.

How do I find the people who will answer?

Use your own call history first, because a number that has answered recently is far more likely to answer again. Verifying numbers before reps call them also separates live lines from dead ones.

Sources